Glasgow English preconsonantal /r/
Abstractions vs. exemplars
Kamil Kaźmierski
Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznań, Poland
Accents 2022 Łódź:: December 8-10, 2022
kamil.kazmierski@amu.edu.pl
Slides available at: kazmierski-accents2022.netlify.app
\(~\)
\(~\)
\(~\)
Photo credit: Rajmund Matuszkiewicz
The most usual Scottish realizations of /r/ are an alveolar tap, [ɾ], and a post-alveolar or retroflex fricative or approximant, [ɹ ~ ɻ]. The first, [ɾ], seems to be particularly associated with the within-word environments [...]; the second, with the environments V_C and V_# [...]. In initial position (#_V) both are frequent.
—Wells, JC. 1982. Accents of English. p. 411
The most usual Scottish realizations of /r/ are an alveolar tap, [ɾ], and a post-alveolar or retroflex fricative or approximant, [ɹ ~ ɻ]. The first, [ɾ], seems to be particularly associated with the within-word environments [...]; the second, with the environments V_C and V_# [...]. In initial position (#_V) both are frequent.
—Wells, JC. 1982. Accents of English. p. 411
There is a range of realizations of R, commonly post-alveolar [ɹ], retroflex [ɻ] and a tap [ɾ], but rarely a trill.
—Stuart-Smith, J. 1999: "Glasgow: accent and voice quality". p. 210
The most usual Scottish realizations of /r/ are an alveolar tap, [ɾ], and a post-alveolar or retroflex fricative or approximant, [ɹ ~ ɻ]. The first, [ɾ], seems to be particularly associated with the within-word environments [...]; the second, with the environments V_C and V_# [...]. In initial position (#_V) both are frequent.
—Wells, JC. 1982. Accents of English. p. 411
There is a range of realizations of R, commonly post-alveolar [ɹ], retroflex [ɻ] and a tap [ɾ], but rarely a trill.
—Stuart-Smith, J. 1999: "Glasgow: accent and voice quality". p. 210
The most common realisation, found in all word positions, is the postalveolar approximant [ɹ]. [...] The tap articulation [ɾ] is commonly found in intervocalic position [...], as well as in initial consonant clusters [...] The trill realisation [r] is very rare.
—Chirrey, D. 1999. "Edinburgh: descriptive material". p. 228
Scottish English is rhotic, and most or all vowels can occur before tautosyllabic /r/.
—Wells 1982: 407
Scottish English is rhotic, and most or all vowels can occur before tautosyllabic /r/.
—Wells 1982: 407
Most Scottish speech is firmly rhotic, with /r/ retained in all positions where it occurred historically
—Wells 1982: 410
Scottish English is rhotic, and most or all vowels can occur before tautosyllabic /r/.
—Wells 1982: 407
Most Scottish speech is firmly rhotic, with /r/ retained in all positions where it occurred historically
—Wells 1982: 410
Scottish English remains rhotic [...], although loss of post-vocalic R is reported in the speech of [working-class] Edinburgh children by Romaine (1978) and in Glaswegian by Macafee (1983: 32). R-loss is also found in the 1997 data, mainly in the speech of [working-class] children.
—Stuart-Smith 1999: 210
Does the variation in the presence of pre-consonantal /r/ in Glaswegian point to abstractions or phonetically rich exemplars in phonological storage?
Does the variation in the presence of pre-consonantal /r/ in Glaswegian point to abstractions or phonetically rich exemplars in phonological storage?
Does the variation in the presence of pre-consonantal /r/ in Glaswegian point to abstractions or phonetically rich exemplars in phonological storage?
Data: HCRC Map Task Corpus (Anderson et al. 1991)
Analysis:
lme4
(Bates et al. 2015) in R (R Core Team 2022)\(\chi^2(2) = 7.775, p < 0.05\)
vowel class
vowel class
vowel | class |
---|---|
a | back |
ɔ | back |
ʉ | central |
ɜ | central |
ə | central |
e | front |
ɪ | front |
vowel class
vowel | class |
---|---|
a | back |
ɔ | back |
ʉ | central |
ɜ | central |
ə | central |
e | front |
ɪ | front |
\(\chi^2(2) = 3.5951, p = 0.17\)
gender:familiarity
- non-rhoticity as prestige variant?\(~\)
\(~\)
\(~\) \(~\) \(~\) \(~\) \(~\) \(~\) \(~\)
This research was supported by an NCN grant no. 2017/26/D/HS2/00027
Keyboard shortcuts
↑, ←, Pg Up, k | Go to previous slide |
↓, →, Pg Dn, Space, j | Go to next slide |
Home | Go to first slide |
End | Go to last slide |
Number + Return | Go to specific slide |
b / m / f | Toggle blackout / mirrored / fullscreen mode |
c | Clone slideshow |
p | Toggle presenter mode |
t | Restart the presentation timer |
?, h | Toggle this help |
o | Tile View: Overview of Slides |
s | Toggle scribble toolbox |
Esc | Back to slideshow |
Glasgow English preconsonantal /r/
Abstractions vs. exemplars
Kamil Kaźmierski
Adam Mickiewicz University, Poznań, Poland
Accents 2022 Łódź:: December 8-10, 2022
kamil.kazmierski@amu.edu.pl
Slides available at: kazmierski-accents2022.netlify.app
\(~\)
\(~\)
\(~\)
Photo credit: Rajmund Matuszkiewicz
The most usual Scottish realizations of /r/ are an alveolar tap, [ɾ], and a post-alveolar or retroflex fricative or approximant, [ɹ ~ ɻ]. The first, [ɾ], seems to be particularly associated with the within-word environments [...]; the second, with the environments V_C and V_# [...]. In initial position (#_V) both are frequent.
—Wells, JC. 1982. Accents of English. p. 411
The most usual Scottish realizations of /r/ are an alveolar tap, [ɾ], and a post-alveolar or retroflex fricative or approximant, [ɹ ~ ɻ]. The first, [ɾ], seems to be particularly associated with the within-word environments [...]; the second, with the environments V_C and V_# [...]. In initial position (#_V) both are frequent.
—Wells, JC. 1982. Accents of English. p. 411
There is a range of realizations of R, commonly post-alveolar [ɹ], retroflex [ɻ] and a tap [ɾ], but rarely a trill.
—Stuart-Smith, J. 1999: "Glasgow: accent and voice quality". p. 210
The most usual Scottish realizations of /r/ are an alveolar tap, [ɾ], and a post-alveolar or retroflex fricative or approximant, [ɹ ~ ɻ]. The first, [ɾ], seems to be particularly associated with the within-word environments [...]; the second, with the environments V_C and V_# [...]. In initial position (#_V) both are frequent.
—Wells, JC. 1982. Accents of English. p. 411
There is a range of realizations of R, commonly post-alveolar [ɹ], retroflex [ɻ] and a tap [ɾ], but rarely a trill.
—Stuart-Smith, J. 1999: "Glasgow: accent and voice quality". p. 210
The most common realisation, found in all word positions, is the postalveolar approximant [ɹ]. [...] The tap articulation [ɾ] is commonly found in intervocalic position [...], as well as in initial consonant clusters [...] The trill realisation [r] is very rare.
—Chirrey, D. 1999. "Edinburgh: descriptive material". p. 228
Scottish English is rhotic, and most or all vowels can occur before tautosyllabic /r/.
—Wells 1982: 407
Scottish English is rhotic, and most or all vowels can occur before tautosyllabic /r/.
—Wells 1982: 407
Most Scottish speech is firmly rhotic, with /r/ retained in all positions where it occurred historically
—Wells 1982: 410
Scottish English is rhotic, and most or all vowels can occur before tautosyllabic /r/.
—Wells 1982: 407
Most Scottish speech is firmly rhotic, with /r/ retained in all positions where it occurred historically
—Wells 1982: 410
Scottish English remains rhotic [...], although loss of post-vocalic R is reported in the speech of [working-class] Edinburgh children by Romaine (1978) and in Glaswegian by Macafee (1983: 32). R-loss is also found in the 1997 data, mainly in the speech of [working-class] children.
—Stuart-Smith 1999: 210
Does the variation in the presence of pre-consonantal /r/ in Glaswegian point to abstractions or phonetically rich exemplars in phonological storage?
Does the variation in the presence of pre-consonantal /r/ in Glaswegian point to abstractions or phonetically rich exemplars in phonological storage?
Does the variation in the presence of pre-consonantal /r/ in Glaswegian point to abstractions or phonetically rich exemplars in phonological storage?
Data: HCRC Map Task Corpus (Anderson et al. 1991)
Analysis:
lme4
(Bates et al. 2015) in R (R Core Team 2022)\(\chi^2(2) = 7.775, p < 0.05\)
vowel class
vowel class
vowel | class |
---|---|
a | back |
ɔ | back |
ʉ | central |
ɜ | central |
ə | central |
e | front |
ɪ | front |
vowel class
vowel | class |
---|---|
a | back |
ɔ | back |
ʉ | central |
ɜ | central |
ə | central |
e | front |
ɪ | front |
\(\chi^2(2) = 3.5951, p = 0.17\)
(1|word)
beyond frequencygender:familiarity
- non-rhoticity as prestige variant?\(~\)
\(~\)
\(~\) \(~\) \(~\) \(~\) \(~\) \(~\) \(~\)
This research was supported by an NCN grant no. 2017/26/D/HS2/00027